Neighborhood Guide: Setauket, NY

🌳 Neighborhood Guide: Setauket, NY

Setauket, part of the Three Village area, is where history and community meet. Known for its colonial roots and scenic harbor, it’s home to Revolutionary War spy ring landmarks, charming architecture, and lush landscapes.

Schools

Also within the Three Village Central School District, Setauket’s education system is among Long Island’s best. Families choose this area for consistent academic excellence and strong extracurricular programs.

Parks & Outdoor Spaces

• Frank Melville Memorial Park – a picturesque pond and walking path. Dog friendly!

• Setauket Harbor – perfect for paddleboarding or evening strolls. Be sure to check out Seaport Deli on your way. 

Dining & Shopping

Popular spots include Bliss Restaurant, Culpers Steakhouse or Ixchel for authentic Mayan cuisine. For coffee or baked treats, locals love Cuppies and Rolling Pin Bakery.

Community Highlights

• Three Village Farmers Market

• Setauket Spy Day Festival 

• Real Estate Overview

Setauket offers colonials, ranches, and waterfront estates, many on quiet, wooded lots. Median home prices hover around $850,000, with luxury harborfront properties exceeding $1.5M.

🩷 About the Realtor

If you’re searching for the best REALTOR® in Setauket, NY, you’ve come to the right place. I’m Shaughnessy Dusling, a North Shore Long Island real estate expert with over 12 years of experience, $200 million in closed sales, and more than 180 five-star client reviews across Google and Zillow.

Ranked among the Top 500 agents on Long Island and consistently in the Top 10% of REALTORS® in Setauket, I specialize in helping homeowners and buyers navigate Suffolk County’s most desirable communities — including Stony Brook, Setauket, Port Jefferson, Smithtown, and Mount Sinai.

What sets me apart is my blend of local insight, marketing expertise, and genuine connection. I don’t just list homes — I tell their stories. My listings feature professional photography, video tours, and social media exposure that captures what makes each property unique.

Whether you’re selling your home in Stony Brook or buying your first home in Setauket, I guide every client with the same promise: work hard, be kind, and deliver results.

If you’re thinking about making a move on the North Shore, let’s connect. I’ll help you understand your home’s value, today’s market trends, and your best next step toward success.

📲 Shaughnessy Dusling, REALTOR® | Real Broker | Serving Stony Brook, Setauket & Port Jefferson
👉 Call or text me for a complimentary home consultation and see why so many trust me as the best REALTOR® in Stony Brook, NY.

💬 What Clients Are Saying

Real results and real relationships — here’s what local homeowners and buyers say about working with Shaughnessy Dusling, one of the best REALTORS® in Stony Brook and across Suffolk County.

“Buying our first home was scary at first, especially because English isn’t our first language. But Shaughnessy made everything possible. She explained every step, cared deeply, and connected us with amazing professionals. She’s not just a great REALTOR® — she’s a wonderful person.”
— Kelly P., First-Time Homebuyer in Sound Beach, NY (October 2025)

“Shaughnessy is simply the best! As my listing agent, she sold my home with powerful marketing and expert negotiation. As my buyer’s agent, she had an accepted offer within 24 hours — even with multiple bids! Her professionalism, kindness, and market knowledge are unmatched.”
— Christina M., Seller and Buyer in Rocky Point, NY

“We took a leap of faith with Shaughnessy 2.5 years ago and never looked back! She sold our home far above asking, breaking a local record, then fought to get us into our dream home in Setauket. Honest, transparent, and treats her clients like family. 10/10 recommend.”
— Amanda V., Seller in Port Jefferson Station & Buyer in Setauket, NY

“Shaughnessy is the best REALTOR® out there! She listened, cared, and guided us every step of the way. She sold our home quickly and helped us find our beautiful new one. Couldn’t recommend her more!”
— Heather P., Seller in Miller Place & Buyer in Stony Brook, NY

“We had a quirky home that wasn’t an easy sell, but Shaughnessy priced it perfectly and it sold in 3 months! She answered every question, recommended great people, and handled everything with energy and expertise. You want her on your side.”
— Ken L., Seller in Shoreham, NY

With 12+ years of experience, $200M+ in career sales, and 180+ five-star reviews, Shaughnessy is trusted across the North Shore — from Stony Brook to Setauket, Port Jefferson, and Smithtown — for her calm guidance, expert negotiation, and results-driven marketing.