Welcome to South Setauket
Located just south of historic Setauket, South Setauket offers the best of suburban comfort and North Shore charm. It’s a peaceful, family-oriented neighborhood with convenient access to shopping, dining, and major roads.
Schools
South Setauket residents also benefit from the renowned Three Village Central School District, including:
- Arrowhead Elementary
- Mount Junior High
- Ward Melville High School
Parks & Recreation
- Bennett’s Pavilion Park – sports fields and playgrounds.
- Setauket Greenway Trail – a 3.5-mile biking and walking path.
- Centereach Pool
Dining & Local Hotspots
Residents enjoy nearby Chili’s, Panera, and local family eateries like Carnival Restaurant and Setauket Pastaria. You’re minutes from the restaurants and boutiques of Stony Brook Village.
Community Life
South Setauket residents enjoy local school events, holiday parades, and outdoor concerts organized by the Town of Brookhaven and community associations.
Real Estate Snapshot
Home styles range from expanded ranches and colonials to modern townhomes. Median home prices hover around $700,000, making it a great entry point into the Three Village area with strong long-term value.
💬 What Clients Are Saying
When you’re searching for the best REALTOR® in Stony Brook, NY, real stories speak louder than any ad. Here’s what local homeowners and buyers across Suffolk County say about working with Shaughnessy Dusling — trusted, experienced, and truly one of a kind.
“Buying our first home was scary at first, especially because English isn’t our first language. But Shaughnessy made everything possible. She explained every step, cared deeply, and connected us with amazing professionals. She’s not just a great REALTOR® — she’s a wonderful person.”
— Kelly P., First-Time Homebuyer in Sound Beach, NY (October 2025)
“Even if I could give 100 stars, that still wouldn’t be enough! Shaughnessy transformed our home-buying experience — turning stress into ease. She’s professional, kind, and deeply genuine. I’ll trust her with every future purchase and recommend her to everyone I know.”
— Katie L., First-Time Homebuyer in Smithtown, NY
“My family and I needed to move quickly, and Shaughnessy made it happen! She answered messages late at night, worked around our busy schedules, and guided us through every step. She was detailed, caring, and truly invested in helping us find the perfect home. She’s now our lifelong friend and REALTOR®.”
— A.S., Homebuyer in Setauket, NY
“Shaughnessy had brilliant advice from the start. She knew exactly how to price, stage, and time our sale — and she sold our home quickly! She was patient, thorough, and never pushy. I highly recommend working with her if you’re selling your home or retiring off Long Island.”
— Patty D., Seller Retiring in Shoreham, NY
“We used Shaughnessy to buy our home and later to sell it when we moved out of state. Both experiences were seamless! Even during the pandemic, she stayed positive and persistent. Her honesty, integrity, and dedication never falter — she’s a straight shooter who truly cares about her clients.”
— Elizabeth B., Buyer and Seller in Setauket, NY
“Shaughnessy is simply the best! As my listing agent, she sold my home with powerful marketing and expert negotiation. As my buyer’s agent, she got my offer accepted within 24 hours — even with multiple bids! Her professionalism and knowledge are unmatched.”
— Christina M., Seller and Buyer in Rocky Point, NY
“We took a leap of faith with Shaughnessy and never looked back! She sold our home above asking and got us into our dream home in Setauket. Honest, transparent, and treats her clients like family. 10/10 recommend.”
— Amanda V., Seller in Port Jefferson Station & Buyer in Setauket, NY
“Shaughnessy is the best REALTOR® out there! She listened, cared, and guided us every step of the way. She sold our home quickly and helped us find our beautiful new one.”
— Heather P., Seller in Miller Place & Buyer in Stony Brook, NY
“We had a quirky home that wasn’t an easy sell, but Shaughnessy priced it perfectly and it sold in three months! She answered every question, recommended great professionals, and handled everything with warmth and expertise. You want her on your side.”
— Ken L., Seller in Shoreham, NY
With over 180 five-star reviews, 12+ years of experience, and $200M+ in closed sales, Shaughnessy Dusling is one of the most trusted and top-ranked REALTORS® on Long Island’s North Shore — serving Stony Brook, Setauket, Port Jefferson, Smithtown, and beyond.