Setauket
Setauket, NY: Historic, Charming, and One of Long Island’s Most Livable Communities
Setauket, New York is the kind of place where history and modern comfort blend so seamlessly that every street feels like a story waiting to be lived in. Known for its colonial heritage, top-rated schools, and calm wooded neighborhoods, Setauket offers a lifestyle that’s peaceful, refined, and deeply connected to the charm of Long Island’s North Shore. For homebuyers seeking beauty, stability, and a community with real character, Setauket is one of the most sought-after places to put down roots.
A Community with Timeless Appeal
Walk through Setauket and you’ll notice something special right away — the sense of heritage. With centuries-old landmarks, preserved architecture, and scenic natural surroundings, the area gives you a feeling of stepping into a place that has value, meaning, and lasting appeal. It’s the kind of environment that instantly makes people think, “I could build a future here.”
Why Buyers Fall in Love with Setauket
Setauket isn’t just pretty on the outside — it delivers a lifestyle that resonates deeply with what modern buyers want. Here’s what makes it stand out:
-
Highly rated schools, including the Three Village Central School District, one of the strongest on Long Island.
-
Beautiful, well-maintained neighborhoods lined with mature trees, spacious homes, and quiet cul-de-sacs perfect for long-term living.
-
Rich American history with sites like the Setauket Village Green and the Culper Spy Ring Historic District — adding meaning and identity to the community.
-
Close proximity to Stony Brook University, offering culture, educational opportunities, and stable economic influence.
-
Convenient access to beaches, parks, Route 25A, and the Port Jefferson ferry for easy travel.
Everything about Setauket speaks to comfort, stability, and a lifestyle where you can slow down, breathe easier, and enjoy the best of North Shore living.
Lifestyle: Peaceful, Scenic, and Full of Character
Living in Setauket means weekend nature walks at Frank Melville Park, coffee at local cafés, afternoons exploring the historic district, and evenings enjoying quiet, starry neighborhoods that feel safe and welcoming. It’s a place where families thrive, professionals find balance, and long-time residents stay for generations.
Whether you’re seeking a picturesque colonial home, a modern property with space to grow, or a peaceful community with deep roots, Setauket offers options that truly live up to the Long Island dream.
Explore Homes for Sale in Setauket, NY
If Setauket feels like the match you’ve been searching for, now’s the time to take a closer look. Homes here are loved for their charm, value, and longevity — and the right one might just be waiting for you.
Browse available properties and discover what makes Setauket one of the North Shore’s most beloved communities.
(49)
Virtual Tour
(41)
(33)
(48)
(26)
(43)
Listing No. 909253
Listing No. 939240
Listing No. L3529191
Listing No. 953436
(49)
$5,500,000
6 6 Beds
6 | 1 6 | 1 Baths
8,750 Sqft 8,750 Sqft
909253 Listing No. 909253
House Property Type: House
(49)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(41)
$1,790,000
4 4 Beds
3 | 1 3 | 1 Baths
4,454 Sqft 4,454 Sqft
939240 Listing No. 939240
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(41)
(33)
$1,288,888
5 5 Beds
4 | 1 4 | 1 Baths
3,000 Sqft 3,000 Sqft
L3529191 Listing No. L3529191
House Property Type: House
(33)
(48)
$945,000
3 3 Beds
3 3 Baths
2,100 Sqft 2,100 Sqft
953436 Listing No. 953436
House Property Type: House
(48)
(26)
$835,000
3 3 Beds
2 2 Baths
1,757 Sqft 1,757 Sqft
950984 Listing No. 950984
House Property Type: House
(26)
(43)
$699,500
3 3 Beds
2 | 1 2 | 1 Baths
2,127 Sqft 2,127 Sqft
918498 Listing No. 918498
Condo Property Type: Condo
(43)
© 2026 OneKey MLS All rights reserved.
Listing courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS Grid. Based on information submitted to the MLS Grid as of 2026. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by the broker or MLS Grid. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. OneKey MLS All rights reserved.